Tag: Documentary Review

  • Over the summer I was able to watch a few historical movies, and a documentary. Below are my assigned grades for the films/ documentaries and an explanation. If you’ve seen any of these and you have differing or similar opinions, please share in the comments.

    1917

    Grade: A 

    1917 follows two British soldiers in World War I who are tasked with delivering a crucial message across enemy lines with the intent of saving over a thousand of their fellow British soldiers. Their journey takes them from their own trenches, across the deadly expanse of No Man’s Land, and deep into hostile territory—risking everything at every step. As a viewer, you are drawn into this gripping and immersive experience, a story of grit, courage, and determination that keeps you on the edge of your seat. The film also offers a haunting glimpse into the brutal conditions of World War I, making its impact both thrilling and sobering.

    Dunkirk

    Grade: B+

    Dunkirk is a gripping World War II thriller that captures the desperate evacuation of Allied forces from Dunkirk, France, in May 1940. The story unfolds through three interwoven perspectives—air, land, and sea—highlighting the heroism that defined the operation. In particular, the film honors the civilians who risked everything by sailing their own boats across the Channel to rescue stranded soldiers. Themes of sacrifice and courage run throughout, as men put their lives on the line to save others. The evacuation itself was extraordinary, far exceeding expectations. With its relentless tension and immersive action, Dunkirk places you at the heart of this pivotal moment in history, allowing you to experience the immense challenges the Allies had to overcome for survival.

    Lincoln

    Grade: A-

    I first saw Lincoln when it was in theaters in 2012, before I was teaching full-time and before I had developed a deeper appreciation and admiration for Abraham Lincoln. At the time, I also knew little about the fight to pass the 13th Amendment—the amendment that abolished slavery. Watching it again now, I enjoyed the film even more than the first time.

    Lincoln remains one of the most fascinating figures in American history—not only for what he accomplished during his presidency, but also for his remarkable leadership, political skill, sharp wit, and the many personal tragedies he endured. This movie does an excellent job portraying that many-sided Lincoln.

    The film primarily focuses on the last three to four months of his life, from January to April 1865, centering on his determined efforts to push the 13th Amendment through Congress. To achieve this, Lincoln and his allies resorted to extraordinary—even questionable—measures to secure the necessary votes. The performances are outstanding, and the film captures Lincoln’s grit, resolve, and humanity.

    Thomas Jefferson

    Grade: C

    My commentary on this documentary is a bit longer than the others.

    Thomas Jefferson is a six-part documentary about the Founding Father and third president of the United States. Each episode runs about an hour, covering his life from his early years through the Revolutionary era, his authorship of the Declaration of Independence, his time as governor of Virginia, his personal life and tragedies, his service as ambassador to France, his complicated relationship with Sally Hemings, his return to America and role in Washington’s cabinet, and finally his two terms as president. The last episode examines his later years, death, and lasting legacy.

    Overall, the documentary was a mixed bag for me. Some parts I enjoyed, while others left me disappointed.

    On the positive side, I learned quite a bit. The series shed light on parts of Jefferson’s life I was less familiar with—his upbringing and early years, his time as Virginia’s governor during the Revolution, and his tenure as minister to France. I appreciated learning more about these often-overlooked chapters of his life. The commentators were knowledgeable experts, and I enjoyed the little-known details they brought forward.

    However, there were several aspects I wasn’t as fond of. First, I expected the documentary to follow the format of other recent History Channel presidential series such as ones on Washington, Grant, Lincoln, TR, and FDR. Those productions blended historians’ commentary with reenactments featuring actors portraying scenes from the subject’s life. Thomas Jefferson, in contrast, relied almost entirely on historian commentary. While there was an actor portraying Jefferson, he had no dialogue—just silent shots of him writing or performing tasks. I preferred the earlier format and found this version less engaging.

    Another critique I have of the documentary was the fact that it did not highlight the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions written in 1799 which, to me, were significant for later history.  These resolutions were enormously significant, shaping the Nullification Crisis of the 1830s and influencing the ideas that later led to the Civil War.

    Another weakness was how overly critical and one-sided some commentators were toward Jefferson..  The documentary clearly made a point to provide a more critical view of Jefferson, which is fine.  But in my opinion, they overcompensated.  In their effort to criticize Jefferson, they didn’t provide a fair balance between the good and the bad.  This was particularly true in the last episode which focused on his death and legacy.  For some of the commentators, their assessment of Jefferson’s legacy was almost entirely negative. and some of them attacked aspects of Jefferson’s life that he had little to no control over.  While I’m fine with historical figures being criticized for their downfalls and they should be, I would have appreciated a more balanced view on his legacy, highlighting the good and the bad in a fair way that represents his impact, without there being a clear agenda to attack.  By ending the documentary with negative attacks, the series overshadowed Jefferson’s accomplishments and achievements.

    Please comment if you have an opinion on any of these.

    Check out similar posts below:

  • I just finished watching a great documentary minseries on the History Channel about Theodore Roosevelt. It was released in May 2022 and was the fourth documentary of its kind that has been released. I’ve seen Washington (2020), Grant (2020) and Lincoln (2022), and I enjoyed each of them. There is also a fifth documentary on Franklin Roosevelt that I plan to watch soon, which was just released this past May. Just like the previous three, the Teddy Roosevelt documentary was very well made. It is two episodes and each are 2.5 hours. Teddy Roosevelt is played by actor Rufus Jones, and I thought he did a very accurate portrayal of Teddy. The documentary cuts back and forth between well-known historians, discussing the life of Roosevelt, and then cuts to the events of his life as a drama. The documentary does a great job adding suspense to many of the key events of his life. You are often left with a cliffhanger right before a commerical break that makes you want to know what happens next. It does help that TR was such a fascinating and accomplished person.

    There truly is no other person like Teddy Roosevelt. He was tough as nails and he accomplished so much throughout his life. As a child, he was sickly and he had frequent asthma attacks. His parents feared he would die young and often kept him inside. The fact that he went on to accomplish everything that he did is truly miraculous.

    He attended Harvard and broke into politics at a young age. His father was a successful businessman and philanthropist, and so Teddy grew up with wealth and privilege. However, just as he was getting into politics, he had to deal with many tragic events in his life. Teddy lost his father when he was 19. At the age of 25, he lost his first wife just after childbirth and he also lost his mother on the same day. To deal with these tragedies, Teddy went out west in the Dakota Territory. He lived off the land in the Wild West for 2 years before heading back East. Teddy became a successful politician but always went against the grain and did what he thought was right. Many within his own Republican party believed he was too progressive. He re-married and had a large family. He served in the federal government in his 30s, working for the Civil Service Commission for six years.

    Roosevelt later became the Commisioner of the NYC police department, and he cleaned up the corruption that was running rampant before his arrival. The Chief of Police was forced to resign and Teddy set up the first Police Academy. In 1898, President William McKinley appointed Roosevelt the job of assistant secretary of the Navy. Teddy wanted to build up the Navy and cement the United States’ position as a world power. He advocated for war against Spain at the start of the Spanish-American War, and personally led the Rough Riders in an assault on San Juan Hill in Cuba. Teddy had bullets wizzing past his head and was lucky to have survived.

    After he served in the Spanish-American War, TR went on to become the governor of New York. Because of his push for reforms, many of the corrupt party bosses in the Republican Party did not support TR. Roosevelt always pushed for laws that would help the common man, and he was always trying to give every person an equal chance. Roosevelt governed with a sense of urgency and had to work hard to accomplish his goals.

    When President McKinley ran in 1900 for re-election, Teddy Roosevelt was his running mate. McKinley won re-election but Teddy felt limited in his role as Vice-President. When McKinley was assassinated in 1901, TR became the youngest president in our nation’s history, at age 42.

    It’s truly amazing what TR was able to accomplish in his time as President. He took on challenges that no prior President had taken on. He tried to crush monopolies and he took on the robber barons (J.P. Morgan, John D. Rockefeller, and others). He personally mediated between coal strikers and business owners, finally landing a deal after a long and painful strike. TR set up a commsion to investiage and regulate big business. He wanted to make sure these big businesses were playing by the rules. Teddy always used the media to his advantage. He got on their good side and knew how to twist a story or argument in his favor. He used the media to get the public on his side, and it worked.

    TR wanted the United States to have an influence on a global scale. He oversaw the deal that allowed the United States to build the Panama Canal. He knew the canal would benefit the U.S. both militarily and economically, as it would cut down the time and costs needed to transport goods.

    TR had such a successful first term, that he won the 1904 election in a landslide. He took on the Meatpacking Industry after it was revealed that the factories used for producing meat were absolutely disgusting and the meat used was putrid (first revealed in the novel, The Jungle). TR believed that it was his job to represent the public interest, and that was his motivation throughout his public career. TR is also known for his preservation of natural resources, and setting aside land for reserves. He saved 230 million acres of land which became public land/ national parks.

    After his term, TR decided not to run in the 1908 election and chose William Howard Taft as his successor. Taft won the election, and TR believed that he would continue his agenda. However, Taft did not follow through on many of TR’s policies, and TR felt betrayed. There was a growing rift between the two men, who had previously been friends. TR decided to run in the 1912 election under the Progressive Party banner (also became known as the Bull Moose Party). However, Republicans split the votes between Taft and TR, handing the election to Democrat, Woodrow Wilson.

    While TR was campaigning in October 1912, he was shot in the chest in an attempted assassination outside his hotel. His aides urged him to be rushed to the hospital, but since Teddy was not coughing up blood, he claimed he was fine. He was asked to be taken to his campaign speech, where he gave an 84 minute speech while bleeding from his chest. He started the speech by saying, “Ladies and gentlemen, I don’t know whether you fully understand that I have just been shot, but it takes more than that to kill a Bull Moose.”

    The documentary goes into TR’s later life after his Presidency. After dealing with his loss in the 1912 election, he went on a wild trip in Brazil down an unexplored river, where he suffered from malaria and a serious leg wound. He recovered and made it back home, but in ill health. The documentary goes into his stance on WW1, and his sons who fought and were either wounded or killed in the war.

    One of the reasons that I love history is because I believe that historical characters and events are just as, if not more entertaining than anything any fictional writer/ author could come up with. This documentary on TR is the perfect example of this. TR is a true American hero who accomplished so much and is such a fascinating character. He fought for the common man and wanted to give everyone a “Square Deal.” Even though he was born into wealth, he was extremely tough, wanted to defend his country, and was dedicated to helping the poor. He connected with the common man in a way that few if any presidents have and he was a celebrity in his day. He also campaigned and toured the country like no other previous president. Besides risking his life in the Spanish-American War, he also asked President Wilson for a commision to lead troops in WW1 but was turned down. He was in his late fifties by that time. TR had goals in mind that he wanted to accomplish, and he worked relentlessly to achieve them. He felt a moral obligation to do what was right, even when powerful forces were pushing against him. He was seen as very progressive for his time, espcially later in his career. He fought for land/pensions for returning soldiers, and wanted to give women the vote. Many of his ideas were accomplished later in history. He truly was a remarkable person and always needs to be ranked amongst the most successful and accomplished presidents. Make sure you watch this documentary. You either have to find it when the History Channel is playing it for free (Which I happened to do) or you can find it on different streaming services such as Amzon, Apple TV, History Vault, or Google Play.

    I’ll end this post with a great quote from the man himself:

    “It is not the critic who counts; not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles, or where the doer of deeds could have done them better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood; who strives valiantly; who errs, who comes short again and again, because there is no effort without error and shortcoming; but who does actually strive to do the deeds; who knows great enthusiasms, the great devotions; who spends himself in a worthy cause; who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who neither know victory nor defeat.”

    Related Posts: